Roofing vs. Re-roofing Jacksonville FL: Which Option Is Right for You?

Roofing vs. Re-roofing

Deciding between roofing and re-roofing Jacksonville FL can feel overwhelming, particularly if you’re not well-acquainted with the complexities of both. What sets them apart fundamentally? Which option is the most economical? Is one a superior choice for your specific requirements than the other? At Red Fox Roofers, we understand these concerns and strive to help you navigate through them seamlessly.

Understanding the Basics of Roofing and Re-roofing Jacksonville FL

The Concept of Roofing

When it comes to roofing Jacksonville FL, the process involves a lot more than merely placing shingles on top of your house. The entire roofing operation is a methodically planned and executed task that ensures not only the aesthetic appeal of your home but also the safety and comfort of its residents.

The journey of roofing begins with the selection of suitable materials. These materials range widely, including asphalt shingles, clay or concrete tiles, metal, wood shakes, and even slate, depending on your budget, aesthetic preference, and the architectural style of your home. Each of these materials has its own set of advantages in terms of longevity, resistance to specific weather conditions, and maintenance requirements.

After material selection, the next step involves designing the roof. This phase considers factors such as the slope, the structure of the house, and the local climate. For instance, a flat roof may not be the best choice in areas with high rainfall due to water pooling issues.

The actual construction phase follows the design process. This phase involves skilled craftsmanship to ensure the roof is not only durable but also watertight. A poorly constructed roof can lead to leaks, which can cause extensive damage to the home’s interior.

Last but not least, maintaining your roof is just as important as constructing it. Regular inspections, cleaning, and repairs can significantly increase the lifespan of your roof and save you a considerable amount in the long run.

What is Re-roofing Jacksonville FL?

Re-roofing Jacksonville FL, as compared to the extensive process of roofing, is a quicker and simpler method of revitalizing your roof. But what does it actually entail?

In essence, re-roofing Jacksonville FL involves layering a new set of shingles over the existing ones. It’s a process often employed when the current roof is in a generally good condition but starting to show signs of wear and tear like minor leaks, lost granules, or faded color.

Re-roofing has its set of advantages. For one, it’s less messy. Since there’s no need to rip off the old roof, you won’t have to deal with the clutter of old shingles and debris around your home in Jacksonville FL.

Secondly, it’s generally less expensive than a complete roof replacement. The savings come from reduced labor costs as the process doesn’t require the removal and disposal of the old roof. Additionally, you save on materials since you’ll need fewer of them for re-roofing.

Moreover, re-roofing Jacksonville FL is relatively quicker to complete than a total roof replacement, causing minimal disruption to your day-to-day life. The speed, however, doesn’t compromise the quality as it can effectively enhance the appearance and performance of your roof if done properly.

Factors To Consider When Choosing Between Roofing and Re-roofing

Age and Condition of Your Roof

The age and condition of your roof are vital considerations when choosing between roofing and re-roofing Jacksonville FL. Roofs, depending on the materials used and the maintenance provided, have a finite lifespan, often between 20 to 30 years for common materials like asphalt shingles. If your roof is nearing or has exceeded this range, a complete roof replacement might be a prudent choice.

Moreover, if your roof is showing signs of significant damage, such as widespread granule loss, curling or buckling shingles, or persistent leaks, a new roof could be the best option. These signs indicate not only surface damage but possible underlying issues, such as wood rot or insulation damage. Repairing such damage is crucial to preserve the integrity of your home’s structure and prevent further complications like mold or mildew growth.

The Number of Roof Layers

When it comes to deciding between roofing and re-roofing Jacksonville FL, the number of existing roof layers can significantly influence your decision. Most local building codes allow only two layers of shingles on a roof. This rule is in place to avoid excess weight on the home’s structure that could lead to stability issues over time.

If your roof already has multiple layers, re-roofing is no longer an option; a new roof will be your only choice. In such a case, the existing roof materials will need to be removed before installing a new one. This process is often more labor-intensive and expensive, but it allows for a thorough inspection of the underlying roof structure and repairs if needed.

Cost Implications

Considering the cost implications is critical when deciding between roofing and re-roofing. Generally, re-roofing is less expensive upfront. This is because it requires fewer materials and less labor than a full roof replacement.

For instance, with re-roofing Jacksonville FL, you’re essentially adding a new layer of shingles on top of the existing ones, eliminating the need to remove and dispose of old roofing materials. Also, as the process is quicker, it requires less labor, translating into lower labor costs.

However, it’s essential to consider long-term costs as well. If the existing roof has underlying issues that re-roofing cannot address, you may face additional expenses down the line when those issues escalate.

Longevity and Durability

While longevity and durability can often go hand-in-hand with cost, they deserve special consideration. While re-roofing can be cheaper and quicker, it might not last as long or be as durable as a completely new roof.

For instance, if there’s an issue with the roof deck that isn’t addressed during a re-roofing job, it could shorten the lifespan of the new shingles. Similarly, a new set of shingles installed over an old, uneven layer may not be as effective at shedding water, leading to a greater potential for leaks over time.

Local Building Codes

Lastly, local building codes play a pivotal role in dictating whether you can add another layer of shingles on your existing roof or not. As mentioned earlier, most jurisdictions limit the number of shingle layers to two, primarily to prevent structural issues from excess weight.

Before starting a re-roofing Jacksonville FL project, it’s crucial to check with your local building department to understand the regulations in your area. It’s also worth noting that if you plan to sell your house, potential buyers might require a more thorough roof inspection if the house has been re-roofed, adding another factor to consider.

The Pros and Cons of Roofing and Re-roofing Jacksonville FL

Advantages of Roofing

  1. Long lifespan: A new roof can last for several decades if properly installed and maintained.
  2. Increased home value: A new roof can significantly increase the value of your property.
  3. Customization: A new roof allows you to choose the material, color, and style that suit your home the best.

Disadvantages of Roofing

  1. High initial costs: A new roof can be quite expensive due to the cost of materials and labor.
  2. Time-consuming: The process can take several days or even weeks, depending on the size of the roof and the weather conditions.

Advantages of Re-roofing

  1. Lower cost: Re-roofing can be significantly less expensive than a complete roof replacement.
  2. Quick installation: The process is quicker because there’s no need to remove the existing roof.

Disadvantages of Re-roofing

  1. Shorter lifespan: Re-roofing may not last as long as a new roof.
  2. Limited application: It’s not suitable for roofs with more than one layer of shingles or those with underlying damage.

When it comes to deciding between roofing and re-roofing, it’s essential to weigh all the factors: the age and condition of your roof, the costs involved, and your local building codes. Both options have their merits and drawbacks, so the choice ultimately depends on your specific circumstances.


1. Can I re-roof over my existing shingles?

Yes, you can, as long as your roof is in relatively good condition and you don’t already have multiple layers of shingles.

2. How often should I replace my roof?

The lifespan of a roof depends on the materials used. On average, a roof should last about 20-25 years.

3. Is re-roofing cheaper than roof replacement?

Typically, yes. Re-roofing can be less expensive because it requires fewer materials and less labor.

4. Can I re-roof my house myself?

While it’s possible, it’s usually best to hire professionals to ensure the job is done correctly and safely.

5. How long does re-roofing take?

Re-roofing can take a few days to a week, depending on the size of